Close Cookie Popup
Cookie Preferences
By clicking “Accept All”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage and assist in our marketing efforts as outlined in our privacy policy.
See inside real campaigns as we “show our work”—revealing our breakthrough insights, donor discoveries, and measurable results for nonprofits like yours. Each case proves how identity-driven strategy turns challenges into loyal, lasting growth.
Explore the surprising truths and actionable patterns uncovered by our industry-leading Brand Core Segmentation Engine™. This case study reveals how precise audience targeting can translate into measurable gains, smarter outreach, and increased donor engagement—proving that audience-centric strategy isn’t theory, but a proven path to growth.
Study Synopsis
The Validating the Brand Core Segmentation Engine™ case study demonstrates how psychographic targeting revolutionizes audience engagement effectiveness. While this study was originally conducted to test business customer responses rather than donor behavior, the underlying methodology of matching psychographic archetypes to messaging is directly applicable to nonprofit donor engagement strategies. The psychological drivers that motivate purchasing decisions operate on the same fundamental principles as charitable giving motivations—both involve identity expression, values alignment, and emotional connection to causes or brands.
Through a controlled A/B test, the study showed that targeting audience archetypes that are aligned with organizational values generated 70% more engagement with only 32% greater reach—proving that finding the right supporters matters far more than reaching more people. Most significantly for nonprofits, archetype-specific messaging outperformed generic appeals by up to 29%, while maintaining nearly identical costs. This validates that psychologically-informed targeting dramatically amplifies engagement and optimizes limited marketing budgets without requiring premium spending—a principle that translates seamlessly from business marketing to donor development.
Psychographic targeting delivers measurable fundraising efficiency gains—70% more engagement and 15% higher response rates mean nonprofits can achieve significantly better results with the same budget, enabling more resources to flow directly to mission work.
Donor-aligned messaging creates dramatic performance advantages—tailored messaging that resonate with specific archetypes boosted campaign effectiveness by up to 29%, proving that understanding why donors give is far more powerful than simply knowing who they are demographically.
Strategic geographic focus amplifies limited resources—targeting areas with high concentrations of aligned donor archetypes improves outreach precision and ROI, allowing small nonprofits to compete effectively against larger organizations through smarter, data-driven targeting rather than bigger budgets.
“For too long, fundraising has felt like shouting into the void, but The Small Biz CMO has changed all that.
Their data-first approach brings welcome precision: an analytical lens that shows exactly where every dollar can make the greatest impact. The resulting strategy blueprint is innovative, mission-conscious, and purposely avoids the transactional practices that plague our profession.
It highlights where our purpose resonates strongest and matches our unique value propositions with the supporters who will truly care about them. Then they take the next step to build the media targeting system to make sure that the people who want to hear our message actually do.
The depth of insight built into their processes is light-years ahead of the one-size-fits-all playbooks I usually see.”
David Chalfant
Director of Partnerships and Philanthropy
Bhutan Foundation
Have a question or a situation that the site didn't answer? Send us a note.
